Insights

News and advice for software sales professionals and employers.

The Search Is Won Before It Starts

When a sales search goes sideways, people usually look at the middle of it. Not enough candidates. The wrong candidates. A strong account executive who dropped out after the second interview. Those things do happen, but when I trace a struggling search back to where it started going wrong, it’s almost always something that was in place, or not in place, before we ever made the first call to a candidate.

If someone newer on our team asked me how to set every search up for success, I wouldn’t start with sourcing tactics or how to write a good outreach message. I’d start with the handful of things that need to be settled with the client and with candidates up front. Get those right and the search has a fighting chance. Get them wrong and you can work incredibly hard and still not get the outcome everybody wants, which is the best possible salesperson in the seat.

Every Decision-Maker Needs to Agree on the Role Before We Start

The first thing I want to know is that everyone on the client side who has a say in this hire agrees on two things: what position we’re trying to fill, and which criteria are most important for the person filling it.

This happens surprisingly often. A software company will have two important stakeholders, let’s say a founder and a CEO, or a CEO and the person the new hire will report to, and they have different opinions about what the profile of the candidate should look like. Sometimes it goes further than that, and they don’t even agree on the nature of the role itself. To use a hypothetical example, one of them might picture a hunter focused entirely on new logos, while the other assumes this person will spend a good chunk of their time managing existing accounts. Neither one is wrong to have an opinion. But if those opinions haven’t been reconciled before the search starts, we present a candidate who is exactly what one stakeholder described, the other one passes, and nobody can quite explain why.

So before we get going, I want that ironed out. Who’s involved in the decision? What does each of them need to see in a candidate? Where do they disagree, and can we resolve that now instead of discovering it three interviews into the process with a candidate everyone has invested time in?

That conversation can feel like it’s slowing things down at the start. It saves a lot more time than it costs.

Every Delay in Your Interview Process Costs You Candidates

The second thing I counsel clients on is the downside of long stretches of time between the stages of their process.

There are a lot of places where those stretches can open up. From when a candidate is submitted to when the client schedules a first interview. Between the first interview and the second. Between the second and the third. And from the final interview until the candidate actually receives an offer. Each one of those is a place where things can go wrong.

Two things happen when a candidate is left waiting. The first is that their interest level declines. They were excited after that first conversation with the hiring manager, and two weeks later they’re wondering whether the company is all that interested in them. The second is that they’re more likely to get an offer from another company in the meantime. And once they have that offer in hand, and your process has dragged, they’re much less inclined to turn it away and keep waiting on you.

So I encourage clients to tighten up the process. Know who needs to interview before candidates are submitted. Know what the next step is before the current one ends. Make decisions promptly, even when the decision is no. Nobody is asking a company to rush a hiring decision. I’m asking them not to let the calendar make the decision for them.

Passive Candidates Need a Reason to Listen

This part does surprise me. There are companies and hiring managers out there who don’t put much effort into understanding what their selling points are.

Think about what that means when we go out into the market. Without selling points, what we’re basically saying is, “We know a company that’s hiring. They’ve got a job. Are you interested?” There’s going to be a certain percentage of candidates who are very actively looking for a new role, and for them, that’s good enough. They’ll say, “All right, tell me the facts and figures. What’s the size of the company? What do they sell? What is this role, exactly? What’s the compensation?” And that’s a fine conversation to have.

But you’re not going to grab the passive candidates that way. The account executive who is hitting quota where they are and isn’t scrolling job boards needs a reason to stop and listen. Without selling points, you don’t have one to give them, and that’s often the very person the client most wants to hire.

You don’t have to be a snowflake company that just had an insane amount of growth in a short period of time to have selling points. I’d say every company that still exists, that hasn’t gone out of business, has some. But somebody has to put in the time and energy to identify them and write them down, so that everyone involved in the process, including an external recruiter like us, knows what they are.

Selling points can come in a lot of different forms, but they usually fall into a few buckets. The first is culture: what it’s like to work there, and why someone would want to. The second is proof that the company is doing well, which usually comes in the form of growth, whether that’s customer growth or percentage growth in revenue. The third is product differentiation. How is your product or solution different from what else is out there? That’s what helps a salesperson picture themselves getting excited about selling it.

Put those together and you have something that says to a potential candidate: this company is doing well, there’s interest in the solution, and this would be a good place to work. When a company skips this step, the thinking tends to be, “We have an opening and we’re paying a decent wage, shouldn’t somebody be interested in that?” And that produces about the level of success you’d imagine.

Overselling the Job Always Catches Up With You

This isn’t something I bring up with every client. But if there’s any reason to believe it’s happening, it has to be recognized quickly.

There are some companies out there that mislead candidates about the stage of the company or about the job itself, and they end up harming themselves in the process. The most common examples I see in sales hiring are exaggerating how many inbound leads a rep will get, or exaggerating how many enterprise clients the company has today.

The person who joins the company is going to figure that out, and they’re going to figure it out quickly. A rep who was told there would be a steady flow of inbound leads will know within weeks whether that’s true. Someone who was told there’s a strong base of enterprise customers will see the account list. At that point, it’s not a question of whether there’s going to be a problem. It’s guaranteed to cause problems. It’s just a question of how severe those problems are going to be.

When I see signs of this, I explain to the client why it’s not in their own best interest. Overselling might get a signature on an offer letter. It won’t keep a salesperson in the seat.

Compensation Belongs in the First Conversation

On the candidate side, the piece that sets a search up for success or sinks it is compensation.

There are two schools of thought out there. One says to ask where the candidate is and where they want to be in the first couple of minutes, and if the numbers don’t line up, end it there. The other says, “I know what company they’re at, so I generally know what they make,” and waits until the candidate is about to get an offer to have that conversation. I come down firmly on the side of having the compensation conversation in the very first conversation with a candidate. The only thing that changes is how and when it comes up within that call, and that depends on why we’re talking in the first place.

There are two ways we engage with candidates.

The first is when a candidate falls in our core space. We get opportunities with clients looking for backgrounds like theirs all the time. Whether we have zero, one, two or three of those open today, it’s a guarantee that opportunities like that will be hitting our radar screen, and their background is going to fit. So that conversation is about them: what would you like to see in the next move you make? Within that, what I need to know is simple. When does it make sense for us to put an opportunity in front of you? When the dollars are at least X, we should be reaching out and talking to you about it. If they’re less than that, it doesn’t make sense, and the sooner we know that, the better.

The second is when I have a specific opportunity with a client who is looking for a background just like theirs, and I’ve reached out to talk about it. In that case, I need to get a little more specific. The question becomes, “What can you tell me about what we should convey to the client about what you’re looking for?”

In both cases, the reason is the same. If there’s not going to be a match, let’s figure that out as soon as possible. Finding out at the offer stage that a candidate needs meaningfully more than the client can pay doesn’t save anyone anything. It wastes the candidate’s time, it wastes the client’s time, and it creates frustration on both sides that didn’t need to exist.

The Best Searches Are Decided Before the First Candidate Call

None of this is the exciting part of recruiting. Nobody tells stories about the stakeholder alignment call or the moment they asked a candidate about compensation. But when I look at the searches that go smoothly, these are the things that were handled before anyone started counting interviews.

If you’re about to open a sales search, whether it’s your first account executive or your tenth, have these conversations before you have a single candidate conversation. Make sure the people deciding agree on who they’re looking for. Clear the calendars. Write down why a strong rep would want to sell for you. Be honest about what the job is. And find out early whether the numbers can work.

If you’d like help working through any of those before you start, that’s exactly the kind of conversation we like to have at the beginning of a search, not the middle of one. 

 

About The Author:

Brock Boyd is Managing Partner of Revenue Talent Search at CMI, where he has spent 28 years recruiting sales talent and has run more than 7,500 candidate interviews. He places mid-market and enterprise sales professionals with software companies, from early-stage startups hiring their first account executives to established sales organizations. Much of his work is with founders and CEOs who are building a sales team for the first time. He helps them decide who to hire before the search starts, and many of his clients come back for search after search. He calls himself a lifelong learner, and after almost three decades in the business he still finds that “every time you think you’ve seen it all, something new happens.”

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Email